What churches in Indy can I get married in?

My fiance and I are both Purdue students but want to get married in the Indy area close to our families. This is becoming an issue as we search for places to get married. We both grew up in religious homes and would like to get married in a somewhat religious ceremony in a church. We are beginning to find out that no churches or pastors will marry us because we do not attend that church, since we do not live in the Indianapolis area and do not plan on staying in the Indy area after marriage. Even the church my parents attend will not marry anyone other than members. Does anyone have any ideas?